Thread started: May 19 2009, 2:36 AM EDT
Watch
I think it's interesting how "Caroline" sort of survives even when her memories do not; her tendency to be fiercely independent as well as her tendency to stand up to what she perceives as bullies, and her apparent desire to protect those who are defenseless victims of such, shines through even with 38 or more personalities in her head at the same time. We actually also saw this is "Spy in the House of Love" though - the only difference is that as a mind-wiped active, she had less of an idea of who the bully/bad guy really was, so she ended up defending the Dollhouse, her perceived home, because she had no idea of how it was exploiting her or anyone else. But notice she still acts "heroically" in defense of it. Classic Caroline... DeWitt should worry; should Echo ever really become aware of the fact that the Dollhouse hurts and exploits people, she almost certainly will turn on them immediately.
I think what we also see here in "Omega", is that Alpha was never that stable to begin with; in contrast to Caroline. Notice how Echo apparently handles the composite imprint better than he does, in the sense that though she may be experiencing "like 38" other personalities at once, what she displays is a much more cohesive set of behavior, with a lot less waffling back and forth on the persona front. I think the "soul" of Alpha was broken to begin with, psychotic and unstable and on top of being sociopathic... and therefore unable to find its way and be more cohesive in controlling the numerous imprints for anything other than largely randomized psychosis or obsessive quests (such as to create his consort out of Echo - nice use of the word, btw!). Caroline, however, though occasionally naive, always had a firm sense of purpose: to fight bullies and protect the weak and the defenseless. And she still does! Sort of calls to mind Book's advice to Mal in Serenity, doesn't it? ;)
1
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you find this valuable?
Do you?
Show Last Reply
|
|
Last Reply:
RE: Caroline Survives Without Her Memories... Even if Echo Doesn't Know It
By: ,
May 22 2009, 12:09 AM EDT
"Silly me, I forgot about those! I didn't remember them until your comment! Hah, maybe I haven't been around mythology in a while...! Nah, but that makes it all the more harder for me to pin down Joss's exact feelings. Maybe Echo is a combination of all of these different goddesses! I don't know, it needs a little more thinking on my part. My brain is kind of in the off mode right now." Eh, don't feel too bad. :) I'm a total mythology and folklore nerd myself, but most of the popular stuff has been handed down by the more recent, patriarchal cultures (such as the Athenians, etc.), and the most popular religions at current (Judeo-Christian, Islam, Hinduism) are largely patriarchal in nature as well. So we see it through that lens. I wouldn't have known about a lot of the really cool stuff before college though; that's when I got access to the kind of libraries and classes where those books are available. ;) I had never heard of Catal Huyuk before I read "Before The Flood" for instance, and that's one of those books that really synthesizes a lot of old and new research on this stuff. Since Joss is both well-read and a feminist though, it would not surprise me if he had been more aware of this stuff and wanting to use it once in it while, if only as a moderate influence or allusion in his work.
out of
found this valuable.
Do you find this valuable?
|